A discussion on the vietnam war

What is her argument as to why the United States lost the Vietnam War. Supposedly, General Giap had written in How We Won the War that in the aftermath of the Tet Offensive ofthe Communist leaders in Vietnam had been ready to abandon the war, but that a broadcast by Walter Cronkite, declaring the Tet Offensive a Communist victory, persuaded them to change their minds and fight on.

In fighting off a final enemy assault, Fox was again wounded, but refused all medical aid. Oh, the immediate reaction would be a sense of relief that our men were coming home. In Julyinternational peace agreements were signed in Geneva, stipulating that Vietnam be temporarily divided for two years in order to separate French and Viet Minh forces, and that unifying national elections be held in July All the techniques of political and psychological warfare, as well as the pacification campaigns involving extensive military operations have been brought to bear against the underground.

Giap is sometimes said to have made this statement in How We Won the War, sometimes in an unnamed memoir. He never mentions revolutionary warfare or guerrilla tactics contributing in any way to his Great Spring Victory.

This was a devastating change to many Vietnamese, as it ended some years of traditional administrative authority of villages, which even under the French had enjoyed autonomy in most local civil matters, such as disputes, taxation, and managing public funds.

Immediately after the war broke out, the U. We knew it, and we thought you knew it. What did the war achieve. The Vietnam war was not lost in Vietnam — it was lost at home.

What strategy did Nixon pursue in Vietnam. What was the war like for the soldiers and marines who fought the ground war. What experience did the United States have in carrying out the missions given it in Vietnam. The DRV also initiated industrial development, labor and taxation reforms, and literacy programs.

The lesson of history drawn by many U. They left under the terms of the Paris Peace Agreements.

Post 1990 Vietnam War Historiography

Casualties, however, were heavy for both sides. That the American experience in Vietnam was painful and ended in long lasting albeit self-inflicted grief and misery can not be disputed. You had us on the ropes.

Panel Discussion on the Vietnam War

Numbers are battle deaths only and do not include ordinary accidents, heart attacks, murder victims, those who died in knife fights in barroom brawls, suicides, etc. Those same media folks also very clearly comprehend, that the American people, in general, are not driven by intellect, but by emotions.

With a good site finally located, Winecoff sent his men across the stream and 35 meters beyond the road to set up a linear ambush and wait for oncoming traffic.

Cushman endorsed the proposal and forwarded it to General Creighton W. Given widespread opposition to the U. But Ed Moise, a professor of history at Clemson University specializing in modern China and Vietnam, noted in a review of the former book that no such statement appeared within: This totally conventional force armed, equipped, trained and supplied by Red China and the Soviet Unionspearheaded by Soviet tanks, launched a cross border, frontal attack on South Vietnam and conquered it in the same manner as Hitler conquered most of Europe in WW II.

The US media is first and foremost a business. Definitively resolving this sort of historical question is problematic, as such examinations of hypotheticals rarely yield objective evidence. The elected officials were replaced by Saigon appointees.

Visits to Hanoi by people like Jane Fonda and former Attorney General Ramsey Clark and ministers gave us confidence that we should hold on in the face of battlefield reverses. Clearly, as the Marines observed the increase in pre-positioning of supplies in forward areas, the need to preempt a Communist attack was becoming paramount.

I have not and do not intend to announce the timetable for our program. The population grew from about 10 million in to 24 million inwhen the Vietnamese began their thirty-year struggle for national independence.

Exactly as they had done in Korea. It is not the South Vietnamese Government. When the French were defeated, the U. The policies established by Johnson and McNamara prevented the American soldiers from crossing those borders and destroying their enemies. What is his argument on the causes of American defeat and Vietnamese victory in the Vietnam War?.

History Devine. Spring Study Questions for Michael H. Hunt, Lyndon Johnson’s War How did The Ugly American influence the ideas of American policy makers?

Discussion Questions

What model of the ideal “cold warrior” did it offer? How did the United States first become involved in Indochina?

Oct 04,  · Origins: More than thirty-five years after U.S. military involvement in Vietnam ended, debate continues unabated over the purpose, meaning, and results of that war. Why Are We in Vietnam?

General Vo Nguyen Giap on the Vietnam War

Over this war and all Asia is another reality: the deepening shadow of communist douglasishere.com rulers in Hanoi are urged on by Peking.

This is a regime which has destroyed freedom in Tibet, which has attacked India and has been condemned by the United Nations for aggression in Korea. 6/12/ • Vietnam Information on the Battle of Hamburger Hill during The Vietnam War, also known as Hill The battle, which was fought on Maywas a direct assault against a heavily defended and strategically insignificant hill, resulted in over U.S.

casualties and caused an. Nov 12,  · Enter the term you want to find in a message, and press Search. The historiography of the Vietnam War and United States involvement has undergone several distinct changes.

In the direct aftermath of the war, the immediate American historiography of the war relied heavily on Western sources, as historians constructed the.

The Vietnam War A discussion on the vietnam war
Rated 0/5 based on 8 review
Opposition to United States involvement in the Vietnam War - Wikipedia